Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

About This Blog

Josh’s Tweet Stream

  • More tweets

« BlogHer: My take on why the A-list matters | Main | Heading to SES »

August 02, 2005

Ask Jeeves’ sponsored listings portends fragmentation of search marketing

By Charlene Li

Ask Jeeves announced on Monday that it would start offering its own sponsored ad listings product that would appear at the top of search results, above similar paid search ads from Google. An excellent description of how it will all work is available at Search Engine Watch. I think this announcement is significant in what it potentially means for both the search engine industry and for marketers actively engaged in it.

First, there’s a fundamental problem with search ad networks like Google and Yahoo! that Ask Jeeves is addressing – that you can’t break out and buy sites separately from the rest of the network. If a marketer gets better results from a specific site, she should be able to fine-tune that buy and be more competitive. Ask Jeeves is hoping that it can give that benefit to more and more marketers – especially those sophisticated enough to manage a separate ad buy on Ask Jeeves from Google. Interestingly enough, Ask Jeeves is NOT going to allow the same sort of site selection within its own network (for example, being able to buy Ask Jeeves and not Excite).

Second, Ask Jeeves is being very smart to not fall far from the Google tree in seeding its new ad product. The ads are exactly the same format as Google and follow the same ranking rules, meaning that advertisers can easily import their existing ads on to the Ask Jeeves platform. Contrast that to MSN’s adCenter which takes search marketing to the next level by adding in demographic, geographic, and attitudinal data, but also makes it much more complicated. The contract between Ask Jeeves and Google expires at the end of 2007. And while I believe that Ask Jeeves hopes that their network will be strong enough that they can discontinue the relationship at that point and retain all of the listings, I think the reality is they will still want to retain some backfill for keywords that aren’t attracting enough advertiser interest. Why not? It’s still a win-win for both Ask Jeeves and Google as long as they are still both making money.

Third, I believe we will see more sites offer premium ad positions in their search results, while still using an ad network like Google, et. al. to backfill. This is especially the case if they have a unique audience that they believe would provide better targeting capabilities – think CNET.com or NYTimes.com. These sites are also eager to tie in their top brand-oriented advertisers, and would like to keep the relationship “in-house” rather have those marketers buy search positions from ad networks. Search marketing technology providers like Kanoodle, Quigo, and Industry Brains will provide the private search ad placement technologies for these independent ad networks.

What this means: Google and other ad networks have little to worry in the short run as these publishers continue to use them to backfill positions that they themselves can’t sell. And it’s unlikely that Google et. al. will use hardball  tactics to force these publishers – the publisher would simply go to another ad network for backfill. In the long run, Google will see some share decline, but more importantly, it will see decline in the echelons of the top advertisers – relationships that it will need to preserve if it hopes to successfully launch new ad products like Site Targeting. A crucial step will be for Google to unbundled its paid search ad networks and allow similar site-based targeting and pricing. It will take the defection of many top publishers before Google will take such a step, as allowing site targeting fundamentally degrades the forced network buy that makes Google so successful today.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c50bf53ef00d8342501f753ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Ask Jeeves’ sponsored listings portends fragmentation of search marketing:

» Ask Jeeves Launches Ask Jeeves Sponsored Listings from Search Marketing for Small Business - Marketing Loop

On August 1st, 2005 Ask Jeeves Inc announced a new search advertising product that will allow advertisers tomore effectively purchase, manage and optmize campaigns on Ask Jeeves and its advertising syndicatoin network. The product is properly named ... [Read More]

» MP3 download, Music CD, Online music from Digital Sheet Music Downloads from Supermusiconline.info
Download the sheet music for your current favorites and explore our ... Download sheet music for Grammy®-winning and related titles, composers, and artists... [Read More]

» The Hobgoblin USA Catalog Contents Page from USA Catalog
This Catalog is for use in the USA only, we try to keep these items available from our inventory here in the US. If you want goods sent outside the USA, ... [Read More]

» Report: J.R. Smith to be Dealt to the Nuggets from to the Nuggets,
physical. The Nuggets will send the Bulls guard Howard Eisley, who has a nonguaranteed contract and will be waived, and two 2007 second-round choices. [Read More]

» Revolutionary Surgical Light Now Available In US: New Surgical Light's Many Benefits Include A Medical First from FDA responded
Systems, Inc.has announced that the FDA responded to the Section 510(k) PremarketNotification submitted for the TRUMPF iLED [Read More]

Comments

Wadim

This very GooD idea IMHO :)

The comments to this entry are closed.